Update Oct. 16. Edelman has finally broke the silence: Steve Rubel’s post; Richard Edelman’s post. No word on what exactly went wrong, or why the “process” that Steve talks about took over a week. More later …
If Edelman is the PR agency that “gets it” about blogs and social media, why did they set up a fake blog for Wal-Mart?
Blogs are weblogs. Splogs are spam blogs. Flogs are stealth PR blogs. And as far as we can see today, Edelman set up a flog for Wal-Mart that has now been outted: Wal-Marting Across America.
It’s a sweet story about Jim and Laura RV-ing across America from Wal-Mart to Wal-Mart – staying in store parking lots overnight. The only problem is that Jim and Laura don’t exist … at least not in the way presented in the now-closed blog.
“Laura” is Laura St. Claire, a freelance writer. Jim is James Thresher, a professional photographer and Washington Post employee. Freelancing, apparently, is against his contract with the Post, which has ordered him to return Wal-Mart’s money and remove his photos from the flog. According to that AP story:
Wal-Mart outfitted the RV and turned it over to Thresher and his partner, Laura St. Claire, who drove it cross-country,
What’s shocking is that Wal-Mart is a client of Edeleman, which is the PR agency is supposed to be the one that “gets it” with regard to social media. But this isn’t “getting it,” and in fact is causing the worst kind of nightmare for a PR agency: blowback on its media-bending efforts.
Not only is the Examiner writing about the issue, so is MediaPost and Editor & Publisher. And the bloggers are not being silent.
What are bloggers saying?
In a word: lots. Here’s a sampling …
This post is not about Wal-Mart. They’ll figure out social media sooner or later.
This post is about Edelman. I’m kind of surprised and a bit amazed quite frankly…as this is the SECOND time they’ve been outed for lack of transparency with the SAME client.
I’m giving Edelman the Goofus and the Gallant on furthering the use of social media in the public relations industry. This tactic could have worked using full disclosure, just interview the customers and get their stories. It might not have resulted in effusive praise for the giant smiley face, but it would have been interesting nonetheless.
On Message from Wagner Communications:
Pro-Wal-Mart Travel Blog Screeches To A Halt.
International social media champion Edelman Public Relations finds itself the target of accusations it created “a phony blog” as a front for client and retail giant WalMart … Arrived home a few minutes ago (8:45 EDT) and have been unable to find a response on the Edelman website, or any of Edelman’s numerous bloggers.
This is wrong on so many levels. And it is Strike 3 for Edelman (not Strike 2, as Joseph Jaffe suggests). Edelman, the self-described leader in me2, in transparency, in Social Media PR strategies. (Or, maybe not.)
Thunderous silence from Edelman
Richard Edelman says that “the business community … must recognize a new axis of communications, the horizontal peer to peer conversation.” How peer-to-peer was the Wal-Mart blog? And why is he not responding to the issue?
Steve Rubel is probably the best-known Edelman blogger. He posted twice today … but not a word about the Wal-Mart account.
The Edelman Landing Blog appears to be a conglomeration of all Edelman blogs. Once again, not a word.
Summing it up
Learn the lesson of Scoble, who humanized Microsoft while being honest about the fact that Microsoft paid his mortgage. Learn the lesson of all the other successful corporate bloggers.
- You want to start a corporate blog? Great. Be upfront about it.
- You want to start a marketing blog and get paid for it? Great. Be honest about who you are.
- You want to start a PR blog for your client? Great. Tell us who you are and who your client is.
You want to do that fake stuff? Keep it where it belongs, in mainstream media.
A little schadenfreude to brighten your day…
Whoops – poor old Edelman – seems like this PR 2.0 thing is mighty difficult to get right – even when……
Thanks for sharing this. I responded to it on my blog Liars and cheaters and people who want to believe. Thanks for making a stand for ethics.
I expect stupidity like this from Wal-Mart who doesn’t seem to recognize that people are empowered now. And there are people who will do nothing but verify something that smells as fishy as this did.
But Edelman? Oh how the mighty have sullied themselves with this one. And keeping to the traditional PR mentality of never talking about bad news again is going to continue to bite them. I guess Edelman really doesn’t “Get It” with this whole new media paradigm and all.
Transparency is not just a nice idea, its a requirement. Disclosure isn’t just a polite thing to do, its the only way to maintain any shred of credibility. Why is that so hard to grasp?
The world has changed and its getting easier and easier to see who’s been left behind.
The way I am viewing this (and I am interested to know if anyone else shares this view) – if they noted EVEN in the small fine, fine, fine italicized print that the trip was sponsored by Wal-Mart, this would not be an issue.
Travel writers accept sponsored trips from companies, associations, boards and clients all the time. The main thing to note is that the print outlet always discloses that information.
That’s where Edelman went wrong. Aah – it’s ALL in the fine print.
Un cattivo esempio di business blogging: mash-up…
Nel mese di ottobre 2006 i riflettori della blogosfera erano tutti puntati su Edelman, la più grande agenzia indipendente di pubbliche relazioni del mondo: 46 uffici sparsi sul pianeta e più di duemiladuecento dipendenti.
In Italia il 13 di ottobre …
Out of the Firing and into the Frying Pan…
Leaving my fancy agency and its cutting-edge online advocacy team in early August was a blessing in disguise…….
[…] He doesn’t have to answer those questions of course, but he shouldn’t be surprised if he gets questions about his silence as other Edelman bloggers have. […]
[…] Here’s the thing, folks – blogs don’t pop up overnight and you don’t need to hire a PR firm to create them. You need to build them yourself, slowly, like a bonsai tree. No time? That’s your call, but a completely effective blog can be created and grown in as little as an hour weekly. If you use a tool like PFFinder or Google Notebook to collect your thoughts as you surf the net, you can be fully stocked with material when it’s time to post. What you will find is that blogging will spawn new ideas in your company – you may even improve relations with your staff (providing your not posting fake or misleading content or stuff that will get you in deep sh$%.) […]
[…] in case you’ve been under a rock lately, here’s a post from John Koetsier at Bizhack that summarizes some of the issues and best lessons learned from the […]
[…] in case you’ve been under a rock lately, here’s a post from John Koetsier at Bizhack that summarizes some of the issues and best lessons learned from the […]
[…] “peccato di trasparenza” ha dato avvio al peggiore incubo possibile per un’azienda e per la sua agenzia di relazioni pubbliche: i media (ed i “veri” […]
[…] especially after watching high-profile campaigns bomb and outrage the entire blogosphere (like the Edelmal-Walmart fiasco or the CAA-LonelyGirl-YouTube […]
[…] things I have ever done was spend an intense 90-days working for Edelman as an SAS on the elite Online Advocacy team, primarily on the Wal-Mart campaign. I was on the team that managed Walmarting Across America and […]